McColley's Chapel is located on Redden Road about six miles north of Georgetown.

The current McColley's Chapel is the second church building on this land, which was donated by James Rudden in 1857. The first church was built by Trustan P. McColley and was named after him; it was the oldest Methodist church in Georgetown Hundred. The original building fell into disrepair and was destroyed in a fire sometime in the late 1890s. The current building was constructed in 1898.

Worshipers attend McColley's Chapel every Sunday morning at 9:30am.

McColley's Chapel is part of the Grace/Georgetown Charge and shares Pastor Maleia with Grace UMC. Services are held every Sunday at 9:30am.